I don't use 'the box', but I have been using my fumble/penalty dice for over 30 years in my solitaire games. Here's my take on it.
I wouldn't play any other way. Yes, there is a love/hate relationship about it. When you throw an interception, but the defense is called for a penalty negating it and giving you a first down instead, you love the dice. When you score a TD, but it gets called back because of holding, you hate it.
Some games it seems like there are nothing but fumbles and penalties, and other games where there is one penalty for the entire game and that's it.
As weird as it sounds, some teams just seem to be more penalty prone than others, just ask the Third Reich. I think they have had more TD's called back due to penalties than any other team.
If I could offer one bit of advice for Reggie, it would be to have the game ref or someone else roll the box
during a play, that way if a fumble comes up, you can stop the play right in the middle and say "Fumble!" rather than waiting until after the play is over. Just my
