WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES IT MAKE: READ

[mantaraydre]

THIS WILL BE ENTITELD ( WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES IT MAKE )


COACHES,

ONCE AGAIN, WHY aren't magnets allowed on safties in some leagues WHEN IT SERVES THE EXACT SAME PURRPOSE AS A SPINNING SAFTEY ON A TTC BASE. WHAT IS THE EXACT PURPOSE ?, TO HOLD HIS POSITION SO WHEN THE BOARD IS STOPPED HE CAN BE ADJUSTED TO RUN STRAIGHT AND MAKE A TACKLE. SO WHY DO SOME OF YOU STILL SAY NO. WHY DO YOU EVEN CARE HOW I CHOOSE TO HOLD MY SAFTIES.

Thank god the mid ohio league sees what i see in terms of magnet use.
once again, why say no to magnets WHEN THEY SERVE THE EXACT SAME PURPOSE. Why have a a saftey spinning around when he can just stand there naturally.

Its all the same scenario in every single game.

1)receiver catches ball

2)defensive coach picks up his safties, Beams in on the dial, turns the dial, places safety back down to make the tackle.


**WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES IT MAKE IF

1)Receiver catches ball

2)defensive coach picks up safeties, beams in on the magnet, pulls magnet off, places safety back down to make the tackle.

IF THERE IS ANY INTELLIGENT ANSWER ON THE DIFFERENCES HOW THE SAFTIES HOLD THERE POSITION AND MAKE THE TACKLE. BOY I WOULD LOVE TO HEAR THIS.

This is a true what difference does it make, why do you care post. THE SAFTIES WILL BE BACK FAR ENOUGH AND NOT INTERFERE WITH GAME PLAY.

Not many coaches wait that long to thow a pass. Too far !!!!

is there any intelligent reasoning other than, " oh, well it's in our rule set "
That's unacceptable because either or is strategic in holding a position.

Realistically, if you saw your opponents safties doing either, HOW DOES THIS AFFECT YOUR LIFE/GAMEPLAN. YOUR GOING TO RUN YOUR PLAY REGARDLESS.

**DO A FAST TEST, RUN A cover 2 and place a safety on each hashmark 20 yards deep. Place one on a spinning ttc and place the other on a rookie base with magnet. Turn on the board, PLEASE EXPLAIN THE DIFFERENCE IN THEM WAITING 20 YARDS DEEP FOR A WR TO HIT.

[styx]

magnets are not allowed because if a lineman breaks free and runs into a safety ,he will not budge,unlike a real senario where the safety would probably get flattened,other than that i could only guess. but i do see your point ,

[mantaraydre]

STYX

MOST LEAGUES stop the board when the runner gets 10 yards or so. Adjustments are made at this point, so 20 yards downfield is enough room/cushion for anything in between.


mantaraydre

[jeff]

If a lineman breaks free and runs into a safety on a magnet and is in contact with that safety when the board is stopped { on a pass play } then that is considered an illegal lineman down field in the Mid- Ohio rules.

[RavennaAl]

I hear ya Andre. Some rules just don't make any sense. By the way Jeff, why would a lineman who is touching a safety be considered downfield, but a lineman who missed the safety and could be even further downfield but not touching a safety not be considered downfield? How can anyone play where the linemen that get out into the field be 'downfield' when these are just plastic figures who can't think and know that they aren't supposed to be past the line of scrimmage on a pass play? Come on, unless you put all your offensive linemen on bases that don't even move, they're bound to break free and go downfield at some point.

[styx]

Originally Posted by mantaraydre

STYX

MOST LEAGUES stop the board when the runner gets 10 yards or so. Adjustments are made at this point, so 20 yards downfield is enough room/cushion for anything in between.


mantaraydre

dre, i understand ,but im not the commissoner ,not every league sees it ,or plays that way, and jeff iis correct if a ol, ventures down the field that far on a passing play it should be a illegal receiver downfield.

[Michigan Joe]

A magnet is like a local brick wall, unable to be moved by another figure. I personally prefer to see prongless (stationary) bases used for stand still positions such as QB or safety. While the stationary base may move a smidge, I like to think of it as part of the game. If the QB stands in the pocket a long time the stationary base may slide around a touch, and thats like happy feet. All stationary bases have a tendency to slide in one direction or another, and you can use this to your advantage if you know the direction. By the way, I find that the best stationary bases are soft proline TTC shells with the prongs clipped out because they offer some cushion to the vibration and don't seem to slide around as much.

Depending on the size of the magnet and the strength of vibration of the board, magnets can have an effect on the way boards run. Usually it creates a very local slow spot. A strong magnet on a small Tudor superbowl board can actually affect the vibration on the whole field. Players actually tend to gravitate towards local slow spots too.

[WEIRDWOLF]

Originally Posted by Michigan Joe

Depending on the size of the magnet and the strength of vibration of the board, magnets can have an effect on the way boards run. Usually it creates a very local slow spot. A strong magnet on a small Tudor superbowl board can actually affect the vibration on the whole field. Players actually tend to gravitate towards local slow spots too.

I second what Joe has said. I VERY MUCH prefer stationery bases to magnets!

[jeff]

Originally Posted by RavennaAl

I hear ya Andre. Some rules just don't make any sense. By the way Jeff, why would a lineman who is touching a safety be considered downfield, but a lineman who missed the safety and could be even further downfield but not touching a safety not be considered downfield? How can anyone play where the linemen that get out into the field be 'downfield' when these are just plastic figures who can't think and know that they aren't supposed to be past the line of scrimmage on a pass play? Come on, unless you put all your offensive linemen on bases that don't even move, they're bound to break free and go downfield at some point.

We felt we needed some random penalties throughout the game .
It only happened 2 times last season.

Also , we do not allow magnet men , only prongless bases or a base with alittle of the blue putty. Just enough so that the player does not move.

[Shabby J]

A total stationary figure in the middle of a field has no right being there to interrupt a receivers route or to stop a ball carrier. It's akin to running into a lamp post in the middle of the field. At least a circular safety moves on the field to some extent.

Then who is to say how close this magnet safety can be placed to the line of scrimmage to interrupt routes disgusing it's intended use a a zone or deep safety.

Also, even though there has never been a cheater in the history of EF, magnets on a field or coach's sidelines are a no-no.

Just my opinion.