The Usage Of Al Reveena's Spring Leg Kickers In Tourney's) Why Are Their Handcuff's

[WEIRDWOLF]

Andre,
Nothing personal here, just trying to make my point on limits.

I'm still wondering if my lead weight lineman would be legal in Andre's League. If he is legal then I don't agree with that definition of MF, If he isn't legal then isn't that a limitation?

[WEIRDWOLF]

By the way, this is the best discussion yet on the MFCA forum!
I will return later. I am off to do unimportant things like my job.

[Reginald Rutledge]

You've heard the saying, "When it ain't broke, don't fix it", haven't you? I know, the DFW League is one that is innovative, creative, and will do things that handicap most leagues. When new inventions come across the league, I am one that champions that cause. Most people probably don't want the spring action kicker because they never would use it anyhow, just like the Triple Threat QB. So as a way to squelch everyone from using it, let's not have it in. I've seen this with figures, bases, and many other improvements to the game.

You've got to understand, the original manufacturers of the game really wanted passing, kicking, and running in the game. Most media want to really see these skills performed, they really do. You ever have the media ask "How do you pass or kick" and the obligatory answer is usually, "Well, we have other variations of doing those things"?

For us, I remember seeing Al's invention come into the league last year. This was a huge improvement on a product created by Miggle that at that point, was inconsistent and really not up to the old school standard. However, with this addition that Al made to Leron King's player, it enhanced his special teams and helped the league as a whole. Not only that, it helped Miggle because then, there was still a reason to buy questionable kicker products if a guy took the time to invent, a simple, yet ingenious product.

Again, we are looking to bury people for their ingenuity. That's why the hobby gets such a bad rap. Al may not want the fight because just knowing Al like I do, he's modest and really don't like a whole lot of attention drawn to him. However, inventions and ingenuity by individuals should be applauded if they truly elevate the game of miniature football.

At the TSO, these kickers are very much able to play. They can also get injured too! But even in kicking, it's not a sure thing as the board will be on. However, with Al's invention, I know of two or three coaches who kicking percentage went up. What a great invention. And he's been using this for more than 30 years, Yall got to understand, Al's old as dirt and his springs have been sitting in the dust waiting for thier opportunity to help win a game.

Great post Mantaray 'Dre!

Reg

It's nice to see that players now want to intergrate different styles of bases, this is really refreshing. I think this hobby is going to excel even more with that kind of thinking. Smitty, you are right, most if not all the players on the west coast feel that way, they play with non-boiled bases, boiled bases, boat bases, munro bases, coleco bases, miggle bases, tudor bases, ITZ bases and who ever makes any new bases. CREATIVITY SHOULD NOT BE HANDCUFFED. I have a mixture of all of the above on all my teams now and I was the biggest detractor of NON-BOILED BASES. Time brings wisdom, there is a reason why there are old fools in this world, THEY WERE YOUNG FOOLS.


Vincent Peatros

[O-schemer]

I like this discussion. Let's automatically look for reasons to include new innovations instead of automatically excluding things because of our fears.

That's what I think is great about David Nichols of the Oxford League. A guy came up from Florida with at least 5 pennies stacked between the base and the player. Instead of disqualifying him or refusing to play, David played him and won. Unfortunately the guy hasn't been back, but it wasn't because his equipment was outlawed.

This guys figures were painted very nice, and it was obvious he took pride in his team, as it should be. We need guys like that. If you automatically disqualify them, you eliminate the chance of something good happening.

Bring on Al's kicker, bring on the boiled bases, bring on the custom figures. Let's play!

[Michigan Joe]

There have to be rules in order to define a competition, but a great point was made that we need to be open minded to be progressive. I must admit that when I first started to watch the hobby from the sidelines, the matter of rules always seemed so divisive which really made no sense to me then as it does now.

I think we should embrace the diversity we have in the hobby regarding style of play- the Brawl championship with the divider, the Shootout with its widely accepting equipment rules, Miggle with a traditional set of rules, Buzzball tourney, etc. How about an MPFL tournament to truely establish that style of play because that style is VERY intriguing (you can't coach AND control 11 players in video games!) Our hobby is kind of like golf which has different courses/venues that dictate completely unique styles of play (for any golfers you can appreciate the uniqueness that each of the major tournaments add). I certainly didn't mean to exclude any tournaments by not naming them, but I am still realitively new to the hobby and my whole point here is that we have some great venues and we should enjoy each for what they are- football camaraderie, fun, and friendship. The reason that I'm even on this board is because of a great experience that I had at Jimbo's college tournament in Gary, IN last year. I met some great quality people, had fun kickin it with football enthusiasts, got to compete in a fun style of play, and quite simply enjoyed a "guys day" which was a nice break from being with my little kids 24/7. That was one of my major minature football expieriences that I draw on and it is one of the reasons why I think this is a great hobby. If I had the time I'd have teams made for all of the unique tournaments. So for those of you with a passion for game I say keep inventing and keep innovating and be sure to post your new ideas at this site!

Joe

[WEIRDWOLF]

OK don't take me wrong on this . I am going to play devils advocate for a second.

Here is my latest invention. It's the lead weight linemen.

Ask your self is this legal to play in your tourney?

My point is that we can't let everything go. There has to be some definition to what we are doing .

As we formed the MFCA one of the first things we put in place was this definition.
The MFCA defines Miniature Football as: Miniature football players on bases which are propelled over a miniature football field through the vibration created by an attached electric motor.

I think that the hobby still has to portray the look and feel of football as much as it can. I don't want to see the day again that someone shows up with 40 layers of clearcoat and all the arms cutoff just to win the game. This is why rules are put in place. That's not saying that rules can't be changed as the hobby progresses but lets make sure that we are moving forward and not backword. In the case of Al's kicker I see it as a forward move. In the case of the guy that stacked 5 pennies under his player, I see that as a backword move whether he won the game or not. Of course that is only my personal opinion.

Ultimately I agree with what Michigan Joe wrote. Embrace the many ways to play and enjoy the company. Most of all have fun and if you are not having fun then either buck for change, start your own league or find a league that fits but always have fun!

In the case of the MFCA skills rules there is no need for a petition. We have a process in place and every coach that is a member will be able to vote on Als kickers after this season of regionals. I look forward to the process and if we can have this many dedicated people casting their votes as we have discussing this topic it will make for a tremendous strides in miniature football.

This is an excellent discusion. Please keep this going.

...some reasonable semblance of standardization. I would love to see the standard weight limits changed to 4.0, 3.6 and 3.2g, but it's gonna take some time for people to realize that your guys perform better at higher weight than at lower weight. Sure you'll still need that Warrick Dunn, 185lber to scat thru the hole, but the whole defense shouldn't max out the weight scale either!

• OL and DL = 4.0 grams max.
• RBs, TEs and LBs = 3.6 grams max.
• WRs and DBs = 3.2 grams max.

Sorry Geno, but 3.6 is even-steven between 4.0 and 3.2.

As far as the original reason for this post, Dre, I agree something has to be done to improve the Kickers. The new plastic sucks and the older plastic TTQBs are getting scarce. If we don't allow the spring as a legal improvement, then we'll end up using our thumbs to fling the ball thru the uprights. Then the new problem will be to ban those guys that have Eagle Claw hand-trainers!?!?!?!?!

[5-13 Studios]

i haven't read every post, but from what i can gather everyone is itching to update the accepted rules/regulations standard that has been in place for a long time. what if instead of doing away with the old standard entirely, it's broken up into different groups of difficulty.

easy (for beginners)
intermediate (restricted to traditional methods of pass/pass placement/kick/etc...and regular base tweaking)
advanced (come one, come all. boiled bases/ spring loaded kickers/ etc...)


there could even be a chaotic division where anything really does go (ok, maybe not ).

I know a guy who's been on the fringe of this hobby for years because no one will allow him to play with his bases. He came up with an idea to make his bases stronger by examming Tudor's very first toy bases. If you put a boiled or tweaked base up to his, no contest; not even close. He's gonna to blow you out! He has the strongest line in Electric Football and no body will let him play!

Yo Smitty, send him out to LA, we'll let him play! As a matter of fact this is what I've been looking for. Have him holla at me so I can get some pointers on his technology!

310-569-1245

Dave Campbell