Favre
 

I agree about Favre...but I think he was looking for non-active players...

Pound for pound Larry Wilson of the Cardinals. Plus Jack Tatum of the Raiders.

LB Ray Nitschke
WR Tommy McDonald(last non-kicker not to wear a facemask)

my choices go to..
 

Mean Joe Greene, Earl Campbell and Brian Urlacher


simple as that...

Hands down,
Tatum!

I may have missed this one, but I haven't seen Jack Youngblood (DE #85) from the Rams on anybody's list. Anybody who plays in the super bowl on a broken leg not named T.O. is very tough. For lack of a better term, he's got some balls.

Keep them coming. I also want to do special teams.
Staring Defense
DE-Ray Nitschke
DT-Joe Greene
DE-Reggie White-Why. Out of respect
LB-Lawrence Taylor
LB-Mike Singletary
LB-Jack Lambert
LB-Dick Butkus
S-Ronnie Lott
S-Jack Tatum
CB-Steve Atwater
CB-Mel Blount
Now I know Atwater and Nitschke didnt play at those positions but how can I leave them out. I do need offensive players including a QB. I wanted all retired players but the QB may be tough to decide. Also, no wide receivers. What I have so far.

RB-Walter Payton
FB-Mike Alstott
TE-Mark Bavaro
WR-Larry Csonka
WR-Jim Brown
C-Mike Webster
G-Conrad Dobler

WRs
 

Tough call there...

Too bad you can't use active players....

I'd go to WAR with Hines Ward anyday...

Guys from the past...hmmmm...

I know he wasn't always thought of as physically tough...but mentally, Rice had to be the toughest WR of all time...he just didn't let anybody get to him...

Why is
 

Deacon Jones not on the list????? I know you all have seen the films he is a serious BEAST!!!!

Already have a #75 with Joe Greene. Would be good on special teams.