Universal Rule Set

[kingATL]

Why cant each league that has at least 12 coaches or more present a video off there style of play. And let the committee put together playing rules for some league to try. The DSEFL play style is like Dixie with a little of SB Brawl rules and Burgess style. We tried this by looking at different aspect of game play. We like having to play more that one game when we meet. This should help the committee to come up with a style. I do think the committee should ask the top winnest tournament coaches to be a part of this process not league champion.

[RavennaAl]

Ok, I’ve been keeping track of this whole thing, and there still seems to be a bit of confusion on some peoples minds about it. Let me try and explain how I see it from a different perspective and see if it makes more sense.

We all live on this planet called Earth. Now, some people on Earth speak Chinese, some speak French, some German, English, Spanish, Arabic etc. One day, a fellow from China decides that he wants to see the world, specifically America, Spain, Russia, Germany and Iran. He also wants to be able to communicate with the people he meets on his journey. So, he goes out and learns English, Spanish, Arabic, German and Russian. At the same time, a fellow from Iran, Germany, Spain, America and Russia decide to do the same thing, so they each also learn all the different languages. They happen to meet on an island and talk. They realize that having to learn all these different languages is not only difficult, it’s a royal pain in the rear. They decide that what they need is one universal language. This way, they only need to learn one other language besides their native tongue to be able to communicate with each other.

First, the American says “ We should make English the official universal language, because America is the most powerful country on Earth.” The Iranian says “Arabic should be the universal language because we have all the oil that you other countries need”. The Russian chimes in with “My country is the largest, therefore everyone should speak Russian”. The Spaniard says,” Yes, but more countries in the world speak Spanish than any other language, so we should make it the official language.” The Chinese man says “China has the most population of any country on Earth, so it is only natural that we should all speak Chinese.” Finally, the German quips “If we had developed the ‘A’ bomb first, you’d all be speaking German right now and this conversation would be pointless.”

As they are arguing, a couple of aliens from outer space lands on the island and listens to them fighting. He turns to his fellow alien and says “All these people do is fight amongst themselves. If they would devote as much time into having one world language, they would be able to get a lot more done. When we travel to other planets, they all speak in one language instead of fighting. Let’s get out of here and go to Tabletophockey World.”

In a nutshell, this is where we are. The MFCA is our ‘Earth‘. We need one spoken word, called Earthian, so that when we travel around, we only need to learn Earthian to be able to communicate (play games) with each other. It doesn’t mean that we can’t all still speak Chinese, French, Spanish etc. It just means that instead of having to learn all these different ‘languages’, we only need to learn one. Then, maybe the ‘aliens’ from the other worlds out there won’t think we’re just a bunch of bickering fools…..

[Megawattz]

Originally Posted by RavennaAl

Ok, I’ve been keeping track of this whole thing, and there still seems to be a bit of confusion on some peoples minds about it. Let me try and explain how I see it from a different perspective and see if it makes more sense.

We all live on this planet called Earth. Now, some people on Earth speak Chinese, some speak French, some German, English, Spanish, Arabic etc. One day, a fellow from China decides that he wants to see the world, specifically America, Spain, Russia, Germany and Iran. He also wants to be able to communicate with the people he meets on his journey. So, he goes out and learns English, Spanish, Arabic, German and Russian. At the same time, a fellow from Iran, Germany, Spain, America and Russia decide to do the same thing, so they each also learn all the different languages. They happen to meet on an island and talk. They realize that having to learn all these different languages is not only difficult, it’s a royal pain in the rear. They decide that what they need is one universal language. This way, they only need to learn one other language besides their native tongue to be able to communicate with each other.

First, the American says “ We should make English the official universal language, because America is the most powerful country on Earth.” The Iranian says “Arabic should be the universal language because we have all the oil that you other countries need”. The Russian chimes in with “My country is the largest, therefore everyone should speak Russian”. The Spaniard says,” Yes, but more countries in the world speak Spanish than any other language, so we should make it the official language.” The Chinese man says “China has the most population of any country on Earth, so it is only natural that we should all speak Chinese.” Finally, the German quips “If we had developed the ‘A’ bomb first, you’d all be speaking German right now and this conversation would be pointless.”

As they are arguing, a couple of aliens from outer space lands on the island and listens to them fighting. He turns to his fellow alien and says “All these people do is fight amongst themselves. If they would devote as much time into having one world language, they would be able to get a lot more done. When we travel to other planets, they all speak in one language instead of fighting. Let’s get out of here and go to Tabletophockey World.”

In a nutshell, this is where we are. The MFCA is our ‘Earth‘. We need one spoken word, called Earthian, so that when we travel around, we only need to learn Earthian to be able to communicate (play games) with each other. It doesn’t mean that we can’t all still speak Chinese, French, Spanish etc. It just means that instead of having to learn all these different ‘languages’, we only need to learn one. Then, maybe the ‘aliens’ from the other worlds out there won’t think we’re just a bunch of bickering fools…..

Revenna has put this in my words as plain as anyone, maybe in more words than anyone but, its obvious that the only way this hobby can gain the legitamacy that we all crave,is to speak the langauge. thats what this is about the feeling of legitamacy as a community is to not only have a standard rule set but also standards as far as equipment. then youll see more cash tourneys, because the coachs from other areas know there not at a disadvantage & playing with unfamaliar rules. Make the rules, set the tourneys, then give the cash back to those who pay & participate. then call it the pro league I bet u have top competitors practicing those rule sets. Until we get serious this is never going to end. stop giving reasons why not, try giving reasons why or how thats true innovation.MW

[Megawattz]

I didnt even see the polling results before i replyed the first time. If making everybody happy is a must forget about it, but from what I see looks like 90% in favor, a definate challenge for the next President, looks like health care on this one. somebody just might be famous if they can get it done.

[eflfanatic]

I did not realize a rules committee had been established. I would gladly serve on it. I have spent a lot of time studying the various rule sets and the NFL Rule Book. I personally think it should be kept as simple as possible and resemble the basic rules of electric football that came with the 60's and 70's
games. I realize the game has evolved tremendously since then and all improvements would be taken into consideration.

As far as the governing body, I am not proposing an outside group. I would love to keep it within the realm of the MFCA but without compromising the MFCA's purpose and mission statement.

By the results of the poll, it seems to be what the majority wants. But again your looking at a very small percentage of the membership who have voted. So is it a true majority?

Please vote and post your comments. Believe me I am very serious about wnating to see this happen.

[eflfanatic]

Ok, I finally took the time to completley read all the posts. I like what is being said by all. I think we are on the right track.

My basic feeling is, if it has been mass produced to play the game, allow it.
That mostly pertains to figures and bases. I am not oppossed to custom figures as long as not grossly over done. Tweaking needs to have some limitations. Not entirely opposed to Boiled bases.

Bring back some skill. Use the TTQB/Kicker TDQB, TDK, old metal, giant Coleco whatever passer or kicker that you are comfortable with and have taken the time to learn how to use.

Whatever game board you want to use mass manufactured, custom, however size needs to be established. Not sure what the most acceptable is now. Home team provides for home team advantage.

That's all for now. More study needs to be done on the different styles of play. That's where strategy comes in as it takes a different strategy to play each style. but that is what I enjoy about playing this game.

I think TV is going to be the major incentive for this and there will be controversy. But doesn't the most successfull reality TV depend on controversy to GET THE RATINGS.

[BAXTER]

EC
I got you, homez. Understood.

KingATL
This type of venture is probably better suited for several types of MFCA members, not just the ones that have won a tounery or two. There are some real brains here in this community that we could really use for this endeavor. More importantly, it would be wise to have good representation from all all four corners of the US. This is something I am hoping will happen.

eflfanatic
Love to have you on board. Please speak with Wolfe on joining the committe.

-Adrian-

[kingATL]

Originally Posted by BAXTER

EC
I got you, homez. Understood.

KingATL
This type of venture is probably better suited for several types of MFCA members, not just the ones that have won a tounery or two. There are some real brains here in this community that we could really use for this endeavor. More importantly, it would be wise to have good representation from all all four corners of the US. This is something I am hoping will happen.

eflfanatic
Love to have you on board. Please speak with Wolfe on joining the committe.

-Adrian-

The reason why I suggested tourney champion , because lot of those coaches travel to different ones. This look like no one is willing to step forward and try to make a playing style for some league to test. While MFCA get the feed back from that league, just to see the results. Our league is young we have coaches who are vetrans and a lot of raw coaches also ,that learn as they play all you BIG GUNS should be able to come up with something for a league to try. You have to start somewhere with something to see what step are missing to make it successful.


Peace